How do tech giants police world leaders on social media?
[Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg, saying on March 25th, 2021:] "We suspended the former president's (Donald Trump) account. Now, many people are concerned that platforms can ban elected leaders. I am, too."
We’re in a new age of political communication.
In the past, the way information was managed from leaders was fairly straightforward.
Now, there’s a whole world of social media sites, which are grappling with how to police world leaders and politicians who violate their guidelines.
Former Danish Prime Minister, Helle Thorning-Schmidt, is a member of Facebook's oversight board.
"They can't make up the rules are they go along [...] all users should basically be equal and that they have to follow their own standards, their own rules."
Here is how some of the big tech giants handle the thorny issue of how to manage world leaders on their platforms.
Most platforms have rules that give greater latitude to world leaders, elected officials and political candidates.
Facebook, for example, has a "newsworthiness exemption", allowing politicians' rule-breaking posts if the public interest outweighs the harm.
[Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg saying:] “The system isn't perfect, but it's the best approach that we've found…”
Twitter says it errs on the side of leaving content up when it is in the public interest, including keeping a record to hold leaders accountable.
[Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey, saying:] “Different businesses and services will have different policies, some more liberal than others, and we believe it's critical this variety continues to exist.”
YouTube says it does not have different rules for world leaders, though it has loopholes that allow certain news coverage of politicians making rule-breaking statements.
Most sites, then, base their policies on a balance of harm versus public interest.
But where the red line of leniency should lie isn’t always straightforward.
Take former U.S. president Donald Trump.
After the Capitol riot on Jan. 6, Trump was banned or indefinitely suspended from a slew of sites including Twitter, Snapchat, Twitch and Facebook.
[Nick Clegg, Facebook's vice president of global affairs and communication, saying on January 21, 2021:] “Was it a controversial decision because he was the president of the United States? It actually wasn't a particularly complicated one to take, given it was so obvious to us that that was contrary to the long standing policies we have in place applied, as I say, to politicians as well as to non-politicians."
Some saw the bans as too little too late.
Others - a worrying act of censorship.
For Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg, the political climate justified the decision.
He said the risks of allowing Trump to use Facebook were, quote, "simply too great."
Human rights groups have implored for consistency when it comes to other global leaders.
Take Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Khamenei, who has used Twitter to call for Israel's elimination.
Or Brazil's President Jair Bolsonaro, who posted discriminatory content on indigenous citizens on Facebook.
In March, Facebook put a 30-day freeze on Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro's page for spreading COVID-19 misinformation.
Earlier this year, it also banned Myanmar’s military after they took power in a coup.
Both Facebook and Twitter have called for input on their rules.
Twitter opened a public survey - and Facebook created an independent oversight board to rule on a small slice of challenging content decisions.
[Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg, saying on March 25th, 2021:] “I don't think that private companies should make so many decisions like this alone. We need an accountable process, which is why we create an independent oversight board that can overrule our decisions."
The board will spend the next six months determining a quote, “proportionate response” to Trump’s suspension, a verdict that may chart how social media will treat rule-breaking leaders in the future.
相關影片推薦
- 1:42【直擊】余天孫子女終於回家了!樂樂緊抱余筱萍 拉著余祥銓捨不得放娛樂星聞66,766 次觀看・13 小時前
- 1:44貴婦奈奈男友父涉捲款逃 重金聘王牌律師辯護華視影音9,782 次觀看・17 小時前
- 1:37虎山巖金針花開了!假日估湧2萬人 聯外道塞爆華視影音12,909 次觀看・17 小時前
- 1:07台鐵舊自強故障臨時換車! 旅客控「買座票變站票」東森新聞影音2,944 次觀看・14 小時前
- 1:188噸全新大鋼牙上陣! 花蓮藍天麗池飯店開拆TVBS新聞網影音10,620 次觀看・9 小時前
- 1:09Lisa大方公開戀情了? 和LV三公子直接同框合照「開心互動影片曝光」娛樂星聞8,123 次觀看・11 小時前
- 4:13電動車舊電池怎麼處理?回收利用!德國之聲6,875 次觀看・13 小時前
- 1:41都更後變無家可歸! 住戶拿70萬怨:廁所都買不到東森新聞影音87,895 次觀看・1 天前
- 1:45獨家》賣家傻眼! 客買化妝品組合「全拆封」竟成功退貨東森新聞影音1,440 次觀看・9 小時前
- 1:08粉絲抱怨IVE服裝張員瑛又獨自美麗 秋天甚至被說像工地主任:只差一頂安全帽娛樂星聞1,704 次觀看・1 天前
熱門必看
- 13:05雪力神分析INF人!精彩到連唐老師都忘了講星座!?Ep.216-3唐綺陽談星室25,812 次觀看・4 天前
- 14:06到京都別只衝伏見稻荷神社 想變美、求戀愛運來這才內行Yahoo創作摩人4,500 次觀看・5 天前
- 11:30【淚之女婿】突變劇情被罵爆... 原來賢祐就是白血球?眼淚是海仁找回記憶關鍵?七大《女王》解析&主演幕後故事Ki笑人生20,530 次觀看・2 天前
- 8:05拿水沖香奈兒!?90萬小廢包沒人帶?! 2024精品新趨勢 永續環保最時尚!!Sherry袁曼軒3,213 次觀看・5 天前
- 7:40花200萬存0056後悔了?4年定期定額0050與0056投報大公開!SHIN LI21,040 次觀看・4 天前